SwitchHosts vs Locahl: Which Hosts Manager Is Better in 2026?

Managing your hosts file is essential for local development, blocking ads, and testing websites before DNS changes go live. Two popular tools dominate this space: SwitchHosts, the free open-source solution, and Locahl, the polished macOS-native app. Which one should you choose in 2026?

This comprehensive comparison will help you decide based on your specific needs, workflow, and preferences.

Overview of Both Solutions

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts is a free, open-source hosts file manager that works across Windows, macOS, and Linux. It's maintained by the community and provides a straightforward way to manage multiple hosts file profiles.

Key characteristics:

• Free and open-source
• Cross-platform support
• Profile-based switching
• Community-maintained
• Basic UI with functional features

Locahl

Locahl is a macOS-native hosts file manager designed specifically for Mac users who want a polished, integrated experience. It's a paid one-time purchase (€9.99) that focuses on ease of use and macOS-specific features.

Key characteristics:

• macOS-native design
• One-time purchase (€9.99)
• Automatic DNS flush
• Automatic backups
• Visual editor with syntax highlighting
• Multi-environment management

Detailed Feature Comparison

User Interface and Design

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts provides a functional but basic interface. The UI is straightforward but lacks the polish you'd expect from a native macOS application. It uses a simple list-based view for managing entries and profiles.

• Simple, no-frills interface
• Profile switching via dropdown
• Basic entry editing
• No syntax highlighting
• Cross-platform UI (not macOS-native)

Locahl

Locahl features a modern, polished macOS-native interface that feels integrated with the operating system. The visual editor includes syntax highlighting, making it easier to spot errors and understand your hosts file structure.

• Native macOS design language
• Visual editor with syntax highlighting
• Intuitive entry management
• Clean, modern interface
• macOS-specific UI elements

Verdict: Locahl wins for macOS users who value a polished, native experience. SwitchHosts is functional but feels more utilitarian.

DNS Flush Capability

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts does not automatically flush DNS when you make changes to your hosts file. After enabling or disabling entries, you need to manually flush DNS using Terminal commands like sudo dscacheutil -flushcache; sudo killall -HUP mDNSResponder.

This manual step can be forgotten, leading to confusion when changes don't take effect immediately.

Locahl

Locahl automatically flushes DNS whenever you enable or disable hosts file entries. This ensures your changes take effect immediately without requiring Terminal commands or remembering manual steps.

• Automatic DNS flush on every change
• No Terminal commands needed
• Immediate effect of changes
• Seamless user experience

Verdict: Locahl's automatic DNS flush is a significant advantage for developers who want changes to take effect immediately.

Multi-Environment Management

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts uses a profile-based system where you can create multiple profiles (e.g., "Development", "Production", "Block Ads"). You switch between profiles, and each profile contains different hosts file entries.

• Profile-based switching
• Multiple profiles supported
• Manual profile switching required
• Profiles stored separately

Locahl

Locahl offers a more sophisticated multi-environment system where you can create environments (like "Local Development", "Staging", "Production") and easily switch between them. The interface makes it clear which environment is active.

• Environment-based management
• Visual environment switching
• Clear active environment indicator
• Better integration with development workflows

Verdict: Locahl's environment management feels more integrated and developer-friendly, though SwitchHosts' profile system is functional.

Backup and Safety Features

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts doesn't have built-in automatic backups. You need to manually back up your hosts file or use version control systems like Git to track changes. This requires additional setup and discipline.

• No automatic backups
• Manual backup required
• Can use Git for version control
• Risk of losing changes

Locahl

Locahl automatically creates backups before every change to your hosts file. This means you can always revert to a previous state if something goes wrong, without worrying about losing your configuration.

• Automatic backups before every change
• Easy restoration of previous states
• Safety net for experimentation
• No manual backup needed

Verdict: Locahl's automatic backups provide peace of mind and protect against accidental changes or mistakes.

Import and Export Capabilities

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts supports importing and exporting hosts file entries. You can export profiles and import them on other machines. The format is standard hosts file format, making it compatible with other tools.

• Import/export support
• Standard hosts file format
• Profile export/import
• Cross-platform compatibility

Locahl

Locahl also supports importing and exporting hosts file entries. You can import existing hosts files and export your configuration for backup or sharing purposes.

• Import/export support
• Standard hosts file format
• Easy migration from other tools
• Backup export capability

Verdict: Both tools support import/export well, making migration between tools straightforward.

Platform Support

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts is cross-platform and works on:

• Windows
• macOS
• Linux

This makes it ideal if you work across multiple operating systems or need consistency across different machines.

Locahl

Locahl is macOS-only. It's built specifically for Mac users and leverages macOS-specific features and design patterns.

• macOS only
• Native macOS integration
• Optimized for Mac workflows
• Not available on other platforms

Verdict: SwitchHosts wins if you need cross-platform support. Locahl wins if you're exclusively on macOS and want a native experience.

Pricing and Value

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts is completely free and open-source. There are no costs, no subscriptions, and no limitations. The source code is available on GitHub, allowing you to inspect, modify, and contribute.

• Free forever
• Open-source
• No limitations
• Community-driven

Locahl

Locahl is a paid application with a one-time purchase price of €9.99. There are no subscriptions or recurring fees—just a single payment for lifetime access and updates.

• One-time purchase: €9.99
• No subscriptions
• Lifetime updates
• macOS-native polish

Verdict: SwitchHosts is unbeatable for price (free), but Locahl offers value through its polished macOS-native experience and automatic features.

Maintenance and Updates

SwitchHosts

SwitchHosts is community-maintained on GitHub. Updates depend on community contributions and may be less frequent. The project is open-source, so you can contribute fixes and features yourself.

• Community-maintained
• Update frequency varies
• Open to contributions
• Self-service fixes possible

Locahl

Locahl is actively maintained by a dedicated team. Updates are regular, and the app receives macOS compatibility updates, bug fixes, and new features.

• Actively maintained
• Regular updates
• macOS compatibility ensured
• Professional support

Verdict: Locahl likely has more consistent updates, but SwitchHosts benefits from community contributions.

Use Case Recommendations

Choose SwitchHosts if:

• You need a free solution
• You work across multiple operating systems (Windows, macOS, Linux)
• You prefer open-source software
• You're comfortable with basic UI
• You don't mind manually flushing DNS
• You can set up your own backup system

Choose Locahl if:

• You're exclusively on macOS
• You want a polished, native macOS experience
• You value automatic DNS flush
• You want automatic backups
• You prefer a visual editor with syntax highlighting
• You're willing to pay €9.99 for convenience and polish
• You want better multi-environment management

Migration Between Tools

If you're currently using SwitchHosts and want to try Locahl, migration is straightforward:

1. Export your SwitchHosts profiles 2. Import them into Locahl 3. Set up your environments in Locahl 4. Test to ensure everything works

Both tools use standard hosts file format, so entries are compatible.

Performance Considerations

Both tools are lightweight and have minimal performance impact:

• SwitchHosts: Very lightweight, minimal resource usage
• Locahl: Slightly more resource usage due to macOS-native UI, but still minimal

Neither tool will impact your Mac's performance in any noticeable way.

Security and Privacy

SwitchHosts

• Open-source code can be audited
• No telemetry or data collection
• Local-only operation
• Community-reviewed

Locahl

• Closed-source (proprietary)
• Privacy-focused (local-only operation)
• No telemetry or data collection
• macOS App Store guidelines compliance

Both tools operate entirely locally and don't send any data to external servers.

Conclusion

Both SwitchHosts and Locahl are excellent tools for managing your hosts file, but they serve different needs:

SwitchHosts is the best choice if you need a free, cross-platform solution and don't mind a basic UI and manual DNS flushing. It's perfect for developers who work across multiple operating systems or prefer open-source software.

Locahl is the best choice if you're on macOS and want a polished, native experience with automatic DNS flush, automatic backups, and better multi-environment management. The one-time €9.99 price is reasonable for the convenience and macOS-specific features it provides.

For most macOS developers who want the best experience, Locahl at €9.99 offers superior convenience, safety, and polish. The automatic DNS flush alone saves time and prevents confusion, while automatic backups provide peace of mind when experimenting with your hosts file.

Try Locahl today and experience the difference a native macOS hosts file manager can make in your development workflow.